Topping:
3 T unsalted butter, melted
1 1/2 C bread crumbs
1 C Vermont white cheddar (Sargento)
Ingredients:
5 1/2 C milk
6 T flour
6 T salted butter
4 C Vermont white cheddar (Sargento)
1 Block fontina (Approx. 0.5-0.7 oz)
8 pieces of Land o'Lakes american cheese
1/4 t pepper
2 t kosher salt
1/4 t nutmeg
1/2 t Italian seasoning
1/4 t smoked paprika (strongly suggested)
1. First put pasta water on to boil. Cook 1 lb elbow pasta 1 minute less than recommended on package. Once cooked, strain and rinse with cold water until pasta is cool. While you are waiting for the pot to boil or pasta to cook, grate your block of fontina cheese and set aside.
2. Melt 3 T butter in a fry pan. Add 1 1/2 cups of bread crumbs to the melted butter and set aside. Measure out spices and set aside.
3. In a small sauce pan, warm 3 1/2 cups of milk. You just want to take the chill out of it, not boil it! Put the remaining 2 Cups of milk in a Tupperware container with the 6 T of flour and shake it together. Once no lumps are seen, add this to the rest of the warming milk.
4. In a separate (larger) pan, slowly melt butter. Add milk/flour mixture to this pan and turn heat up to high. Wisk vigorously until mixture comes to a full boil. Make sure this gets to a thick gravy consistency - if not there by the time it boils, cook a few more minutes.
5. Add salt, pepper and all the spices. (This part if customizable so if you prefer a different blend of ingredients, here's one of the areas you can customize.) Stir in spices and then slowly add all the cheese stirring constantly until completely blended. The cheese combination is also customizable. Jarlsberg is a great sub for Fontina giving a bit more of a bite. We haven't tried yet, but regular or smoked gouda is a sub for the Fontina as well. Experiment to find your favorite blend.
6. Combine pasta into the cheese mixture. Stir gently so as not to break the pasta apart. This should appear very soupy looking. Let mixture sit while you pre heat oven to broil. Mixture can also be set aside until ready to serve.
7. Pour Mac & Cheese into a 13x9 pan. Top with 1 cup of cheddar cheese and bread crumb mixture. Broil until bread crumbs brown approx. 5 minutes. (NOTE: if you don't like a saucier mac and cheese, bake for 25 minutes on 350 rather than broil topping. If you choose to do this, brown bread crumbs in the fry pan when you combine with the butter.)
As you can see, lots of ways to do this, but now you have the way we love it! I couldn't get a shot of the finished product before everyone dug in, so here's a half eaten one :)
ENJOY!